At breakfast and beyond, the sandwich is America’s favorite menu item. It drove the rise of the fast casual segment, is the core competency of the quick service segment, dominates fine dining lunches and is the top-selling item at many casual chains. In fact, Americans will eat more than 12 billion sandwiches this year, according to Packaged Facts citing data from NPD Group. That’s one billion more sandwiches sold in foodservice than in 2005. Technomic polled customers and found that more than 93 percent purchase at least one sandwich a week away from home. The Sandwich is America’s favorite menu item because it delivers on the desires of dining consumers: regional and international flavors, choice, control and portability.
High quality sandwiches are popular because they provide bold flavor profiles and practicality. Consumers will try new flavors on sandwiches because the cost of trial is relatively low. Operators are also more daring with sandwich flavors, offering a variety of new flavors because they can serve them on a handheld, portable sandwich. But the Sandwich’s greatest appeal is customization. According to Mintel, 58 percent of restaurant-goers are more satisfied when they can customize their orders, and sandwiches give operators the flexibility to make it happen.
Pork is making an impact in sandwiches. Traditionally, ham, bacon and sausage have driven the demand for pork sandwiches; today, chefs are getting creative with pork sandwich options like pulled pork, meatballs, tenderloin and chops. Southeast Asian sandwiches made with pork are growing in popularity, like the Korean ssam, the Chinese bao, and the Vietnamese bánh mì. All three traditionally feature pork and are showing up on menus across the country. Chefs are also taking innovative approaches to ham, using flavored or regional hams in traditional sandwiches like the Monte Cristo. Cured pork, once the domain of charcuterie plates, is perfect on sandwiches, wraps and paninis. Latin additions like Cubans, tortas and cemitas are also on the rise.

Driven by street food operators and mom-and-pop ethnic restaurants, the bánh mì sandwich is one of the latest hits in restaurants. Just a few years ago, the bành mì was only found in Asian neighborhoods. Now, Top Chef Michael Voltaggio features a bánh mì made with pork belly, pork butt, chicharrónes and pickled vegetables at his L.A. sandwich shop Ink Sack. ShopHouse Southeast Asian Kitchen, the newest addition from the owners of Chipotle, offers a bánh mì with pork meatballs served with green papaya slaw, peanuts and herb salad. Even Whole Foods is getting in on the trend with a line of bánh mì sandwiches at their deli station.
The Cuban sandwich, and its cousin the Medianoche, have been popular in South Florida for decades, but due to their simplicity and great flavor, they can now be found across mainstream menus. The traditional Cuban is made with roast pork, ham, pickles and Swiss cheese, and restaurants are creating their own signature Cubans, like the Cheesecake Factory’s variation made with pork belly and ham.
Almost every city and region has its own signature sandwich style, layered with the indigenous flavors of emerging ethnic populations. From Tom+Chee’s Grilled Cheese with Bacon on two slices of grilled donut in Cincinnati, to Manzana a restaurant in Oswego, Oregon that features a citrus-glazed pork tenderloin sandwich with fire-roasted pork, barbecue onion relish, smoked mozzarella and chipotle remoulade. There is no arguing, sandwiches are the perfect showcase for a city’s favorite flavors.
So it’s official: America loves a good sandwich. To explore the amazing range of sandwiches menued across the country, we checked out the sandwich scene in three cities – New York City, Indianapolis, and San Francisco.
New York City’s About International Flair
With a diverse population and ethnic identity driving culinary creation, New York City is full of international flavor. Hundreds of original and authentic pork sandwiches are found around the city, from Italian and Latin favorites to the flavors of Southeast Asia. Food blog “Between the Bread” identifies the two most popular sandwich options in NYC: Cubans and Porchetta. New York Magazine and City Unlisted both swear by the restaurant Porchetta, a small establishment located in the East Village.
Porchetta, of course, is home to the Porchetta Sandwich, which was lauded by City Unlisted saying, “this is not a sandwich, it’s a phenomenon…It offers roasted pork prepared in the Italian style, seasoned with aromatic herbs and spices, with crispy skin that breaks off into squares which explode in your mouth like little, fabulous fat bombs.” The sandwich features a whole deboned pig seasoned with fennel and other spices, slow-roasted until the skin is crackling and the meat is juicy. The porchetta sandwich on ciabatta at Di Palo Dairy also made New York Magazine’s “Best Sandwiches in New York.”

It’s not just Porchetta that makes New Yorker’s mouths water. Pulled pork stars at restaurants like Num Pang, a Cambodian restaurant in Greenwich Village. Their pulled pork is served bánh mì style with cucumber, pickled carrots, cilantro and chili mayo. They also feature a pork sparerib sandwich with spicy tamarind glaze and a five-spice glazed pork belly with pickled Asian pear. In the East Village, Xe May takes a multi-cultural approach to the bánh mì with an Italian-Vietnamese version made with grilled pork meatballs covered in house-made tomato sauce and provolone with cilantro, pickled carrots, daikon, cucumber and chili mayo all served on a traditional baguette.
Cubans and roast pork sandwiches are highlighted at Defonte’s Sandwich Shop, where roast pork is served with broccoli rabe and provolone. At Tom Colicchio’s ‘wichcraft. Colicchio serves one version with coppa, pickled pepper relish and Fontina on grilled country bread, as well as another roast pork sandwich with Dijon mustard and bread and butter pickles on ciabatta. Cubanos are also popular at Colicchio & Sons and The Spotted Pig, not to mention the numerous Cuban restaurants around the city.
In addition to Cubans, Latin-inspired flavors are taking New York City by storm. Caracas, a Venezuelan restaurant with locations in Manhattan and Brooklyn, offers two pork arepas: La de Pernil and Los Muchachos. La de Pernil is roasted pork shoulder with tomato slices and spicy mango sauce, while Muchadoes features grilled chorizo, spicy white cheese with jalapenos and sautéed peppers. Both arepas are served on 100 percent corn flour buns and are either grilled or baked.
Indianapolis Equals Regional Perfection

Indiana, the fifth largest pork-producing state, is clearly full of pork lovers. Their sandwich of choice is the breaded pork tenderloin. Nick’s Kitchen in Huntington offers the Original Pork Tenderloin Sandwich, first made in 1908 and a favorite ever since. The sandwich is made using the original recipe, which includes a buttermilk soak and a coating of cracker crumbs. In Indianapolis, variations on the breaded tenderloin sandwich are ubiquitous, found from Plump’s Last Shot and Mug n’ Bun, to The Friendly Tavern and Gerst Bavarian Haus, and almost everywhere in between. Standard toppings for all include lettuce, tomato, red onions, and pickles.

Indy also boasts two stand out Cuban sandwiches, from Tortas Guicho Dominguez y El Cubanito and Super Tortas Estilo Barrio. At Dominguez, the Cuban sandwich is the size of a bear paw and features a mixture of roast pork, ham, turkey, Mexican sausage, breaded steak and a hot dog. It’s served with American cheese, mozzarella, white queso, pineapple, tomato, jalapeno and avocado. Its biggest competitor is Barrio’s sandwich, with two pounds of meat and cheese, a fried egg, avocado and jalapenos.
Pork Po’Boys are growing in popularity in Indianapolis as well. Papa Roux’s started the craze with a Cajun-style pork sandwich with their signature Vouxdoux mayo and coleslaw, and others are following suit.
San Francisco Sandwich Sensations
San Francisco offers the sandwich lover a buffet of international options with a focus on Asian cuisine. It's home to the bánh mì fast-casual restaurant Bun Mee, which has a menu that makes the bánh mì experience very approachable for many newcomers. They serve traditional and Americanized versions as well as the Bun Mee Combo, featuring grilled lemongrass pork, paté, mortadella, garlic aioli, shaved onion, pickled carrot and daikon, cucumber, jalapenos and cilantro. Lee's Sandwiches, one of the country’s largest bánh mì chains, is based in the Bay Area, now has 43 units in five states after getting it's start as a food truck. Their classic Lee’s Combination is a delicious sandwich with sliced ham, headcheese and paté.

According to Endless Simmer’s “America’s Best New Sandwiches of 2012,” the number one new sandwich in the U.S. is the Irish Breakfast Sandwich served at Beachside in San Francisco. Made with thick slabs of bacon, pork sausage, blood pudding, and Whit (oatmeal-pork fat) pudding, the sandwich also features grilled tomato, a fried egg, garlic aioli and tamarind sauce.

For the more mobile at heart, food truck Ebbett’s Good to Go serves a version of the Cuban with pulled pork, artisan ham, Gruyère, jalapeno relish and chipotle mayo.

For Pulled Pork sandwiches, some of the best are offered at The Southern Sandwich Company, The Rib Whip, 3-SUM Eats Food Truck (Cuban), Saigon Sandwich and Wooly Pig Café whose signature namesake sandwich has pork belly, arugula, shallots and garlic. Not to be outdone by New York, Roti Roti Gourmet Rotisserie features porchetta with arugula, sweet onions and sea salt.
The sandwich is a canvas that provides chefs with ultimate creativity and flexibility, and its popularity in restaurants across the country continues to grow. It offers international flavor, homestyle comfort, artisan appeal, and for America’s restaurants, it remains the most be-wiching item on the menu.